This example shows a drop test of a fluid-filled plastic bottle.
The following Abaqus features are demonstrated:
using the volume fraction tool in Abaqus/CAE to model complex material distributions in an Eulerian element mesh,
using the Eulerian-Lagrangian contact formulation to simulate a highly dynamic event
involving a fluid material (modeled using Eulerian elements) interacting with structural
boundaries (modeled using Lagrangian elements),
using the smoothed particle hydrodynamic (SPH) method to
analyze a highly dynamic event in a purely Lagrangian environment, and
converting continuum finite elements to SPH particles to
analyze the highly dynamic event.
Simulation is commonly used in the consumer packaging industry to reduce the time and cost
associated with physical prototyping. Drop tests, which simulate an object falling and
impacting a hard surface, are often used to investigate the object's response under harsh
handling conditions.
This example involves a fluid-filled plastic bottle falling from a height of roughly 300 mm
onto a flat, rigid floor. The bottle, as shown in Figure 1, is a rectangular jug made of high-density polyethylene. The bottle is filled almost
completely (about 95%) with water. A realistic simulation for the bottle must account for
both the exterior forces on the bottle from the floor impact, as well as the interior forces
of the water pushing against the bottle. Resulting stresses and strains in the bottle can be
used to determine its structural feasibility.
Geometry
Figure 1 shows the pertinent dimensions for the bottle and cap model. The bottle has a uniform
thickness of 0.5 mm, with the exception of the rim around the bottle's mouth; the rim is
0.65 mm thick. The bottle's cap is modeled as a separate part instance and positioned on
the mouth of the bottle; the cap is uniformly 1 mm thick.
The bottle strikes the floor at a skew angle, with one of the bottom corners experiencing
the initial impact. Figure 2 shows the assembled model. Initially the water in the bottle is distributed according
to a gravitational response; that is, the boundary of the water is parallel to the
horizontal floor, not to the bottom of the skewed bottle.
Materials
The bottle is constructed of high-density polyethylene that follows an isotropic plastic
hardening model.
The water is treated as a nearly incompressible, nearly inviscid Newtonian fluid.
Boundary conditions and loading
The entire model is subject to a gravity load. The rigid floor is fixed in place.
Interactions
The bottle contacts three different model components over the course of the analysis: the
floor, the bottle cap, and the water within the bottle. All of these contact interactions
are assumed to be frictionless.
Abaqus modeling approaches and simulation techniques
The primary challenge to solving this problem is the highly transient fluid-structure
interaction between the water and the bottle. In this example two methods are studied. The
coupled Eulerian-Lagrangian (CEL) analysis technique in Abaqus/Explicit is well suited to handling problems of this nature. The
SPH method can be used to model the violent sloshing
associated with the impact.
Summary of analysis cases
Case 1
Coupled Eulerian-Lagrangian analysis.
Case 2
SPH analysis.
Case 3
Finite element conversion to
SPH particle analysis.
Mesh design
The bottle is imported as an orphan mesh of
S3R and
S4R elements. The cap geometry is meshed
with S4R elements. Figure 3 shows the assembled mesh for the bottle and cap. The floor is meshed with surface
elements of type SFM3D4R; a rigid body
constraint is subsequently applied to these elements (see Constraints below).
Materials
An elastic-plastic material definition is used for the polyethylene in the bottle, with
the isotropic hardening curve defined by the data points in Table 1; the onset of plastic yielding occurs at 8.618 N/mm2, and failure occurs at
a strain of 0.59. Damage is incorporated using a ductile damage definition. The
high-density polyethylene has a density of 8.76 × 10−7 kg/mm3,
Young's modulus of 903.114 N/mm2, and Poisson's ratio of 0.39.
The water is modeled using the linear Hugoniot form of the Mie-Grüneisen equation of state; the equation
parameters appear in Table 2. The water has a density of 9.96 × 10−7 kg/mm3 and bulk modulus
of 2.094 GPa. The SPH analyses use the ton-mm-s unit and
has a density of 9.96 × 10-10 ton/mm3 and bulk modulus of 0.02094
GPa. The sound speed used for SPH analyses is 1.45 ×
105 mm/s to speed up the simulation.
Boundary conditions
An encastre boundary condition is applied to the reference point of the rigid floor to
fix it in place for the duration of the analysis.
Loads
A gravity load is applied to the bottle, cap, and water instances. An acceleration of
−9800 mm/s2 is applied in the z-direction.
Predefined fields
Instead of simulating the full dropping event from the initial position, the bottle, cap,
and water instances are positioned close to the floor and prescribed an initial velocity
predefined field. An initial velocity of −2444 mm/s in the
z-direction corresponds to the speed that would be attained by an
object falling about 300 mm from rest under typical gravitational acceleration.
Constraints
A rigid body constraint applied to the floor part instance makes the floor a simple,
undeformable surface.
Interactions
General contact is defined for the model. General contact enforces interactions between
the bottle and other Lagrangian components, such as the cap and floor. The default
frictionless hard contact property governs all interactions.
In an actual bottle, the cap would be firmly attached to the neck of the bottle. This
interaction between the bottle and the cap is considered insignificant for the purposes of
this analysis. Instead of adding undue cost to the analysis by modeling a threaded
connection or tie constraint between the two parts, the cap is allowed to freely detach
from the bottle during the simulation.
Output requests
Displacements, velocities, and accelerations are requested for the bottle and cap.
Logarithmic strain (LE) and equivalent
plastic strain (PEEQ) are requested for
the bottle to assess its structural response. Damage initiation criteria
(DMICRT) and element status
(STATUS) are also requested for the
polyethylene bottle to track potential failure in these components. Finally, contact
stresses (CSTRESS) and contact forces
(CFORCE) are requested for the
Lagrangian part instances.
Case 1 Coupled Eulerian-Lagrangian analysis
This case shows the use of the Eulerian-Lagrangian contact formulation to simulate the
bottle drop with the fluid material (modeled using Eulerian elements) interacting with
structural boundaries (modeled using Lagrangian elements). In
addition, the volume fraction tool in Abaqus/CAE is used to model complex material distributions in an Eulerian element mesh.
Analysis types
The full simulation is conducted in a single explicit dynamic step lasting 0.05 s.
A few distorted Lagrangian elements in the model are controlling the stable time
increment, thus dictating the time to complete the analysis. Using the semiautomatic mass
scaling method, the time increment can be increased to 7.528 × 10−7 s, reducing
the analysis cost by nearly half, while increasing the total mass by only 0.11 percent.
Alternatively, using the mass adjustment method, the mass can be redistributed among the
elements of the bottle to achieve the same time increment without affecting the total mass
of the bottle. A large number of elements have mass in excess of what is required to
achieve the above stable time increment. Only 0.12 percent of this excess mass is
redistributed to the remaining elements to raise their time increment to the specified
value. In both methods, the change in the mass distribution is very small and does not
significantly influence the analysis results.
Analysis Techniques
The Eulerian element formulation allows the analysis of bodies undergoing severe
deformation without the difficulties traditionally associated with mesh distortion. In an
Eulerian mesh material flows through fixed elements, so a well-defined mesh at the start
of an analysis remains well-defined throughout the analysis. Although Eulerian material
boundaries are more approximate than traditional Lagrangian element boundaries, the
Eulerian formulation allows you to capture extreme deformation phenomena such as fluid
flow. The water is modeled using an Eulerian element domain. The bottle—which, although
significantly stiffer than the water, is not rigid—is modeled using traditional Lagrangian
shell elements. The general contact algorithm in Abaqus/Explicit tracks and enforces contact between the Eulerian material boundary and the Lagrangian
elements, enabling effective simulation of the fluid-structure interaction.
Mesh design
The Eulerian mesh, which serves as the domain through which the water material can flow,
is a 300 × 250 × 200 mm rectangular prism of
EC3D8R elements. Each Eulerian element is a
regular cube measuring 5 mm on an edge. The Eulerian mesh completely encompasses the
bottle and cap, and it extends slightly below the floor. Any interface that is expected to
experience Eulerian-Lagrangian contact must be located within the Eulerian mesh; once an
Eulerian material passes beyond the boundaries of the Eulerian mesh, it is lost to the
simulation and contact is not enforced. The overlapping of Lagrangian and Eulerian
elements is acceptable because these two element types do not interact with each other.
Lagrangian elements interact only with Eulerian material within the mesh. The initial
position of this Eulerian material must be defined within the Eulerian mesh, as discussed
in Initial conditions below.
Initial conditions
Because an Eulerian mesh is void of any material by default, the desired distribution of
material within the Eulerian mesh must be specified using an initial condition. This
distribution is defined using the concept of an Eulerian volume fraction, or the
percentage of an element that is occupied by a given material. For each Eulerian element
that initially contains material, an initial Eulerian volume fraction for that material
must be specified. Abaqus evaluates all the element volume fractions to determine the distribution and boundaries
of Eulerian materials within the Eulerian mesh.
Abaqus/CAE provides tools that greatly simplify the definition of initial material volume
fractions, particularly for complex geometries. The desired material geometry can be
modeled as a separate part (the reference part), then instanced into the Eulerian mesh in
a position that corresponds to the intended material position. The volume fraction tool
performs a Boolean comparison between the Eulerian mesh and the reference part, then
creates a discrete field that associates each element in the mesh with a percentage based
on the amount of space occupied by the reference part within that element. This discrete
field can be used in a material assignment predefined field to specify the appropriate
Eulerian volume fractions for a particular material.
A part corresponding to the geometry of the water in the bottle is
provided with this example (cel_bottle_drop_watergeom.sat). This part
is imported into Abaqus/CAE, then instanced and oriented in the model assembly with the other part instances. The
volume fraction tool uses the water geometry as the reference part instance within the
Eulerian part instance (the Eulerian part must be meshed before using the tool). The
resulting discrete field is used to create a water material assignment predefined field in
the Load module. This material assignment distributes the water in the Eulerian mesh in a geometry
corresponding to the water geometry part instance. The water geometry instance is
subsequently suppressed to remove it from the model.
Although it is not used in the script for this example, a solid version
of the bottle geometry is also available
(cel_bottle_drop_solidgeom.sat). The water reference geometry can
be created from this solid bottle using geometry cuts in the Assembly module (see Performing Boolean operations on part instances).
Predefined fields
The initial material assignment for the Eulerian mesh is also defined in Abaqus/CAE with a predefined field. A material assignment predefined field associates the discrete
field that was created by the volume fraction tool (see Initial conditions) with the water material
definition.
Interactions
The contact between the bottle and the Eulerian material initially positioned inside of
the bottle is also modeled using the general contact algorithm.
Output requests
In addition to the field and history output requests listed above, the Eulerian volume
fraction output variable (EVF) is
requested as field output to visualize geometric results.
Case 2 SPH analysis
This case shows the use of a smoothed particle hydrodynamic
(SPH) analysis to analyze the fluid-filled bottle drop in
a purely Lagrangian environment.
Analysis types
The full simulation is conducted in a single explicit dynamic step lasting 0.05 s.
Analysis Techniques
The water is modeled using continuum pseudo-particles. Internally, Abaqus/Explicit determines automatically every increment of the analysis that are the active neighbors
associated with a given particle of interest to apply the
SPH formulation. Since the internally determined
connectivity is allowed to change every increment, the method robustly handles the severe
deformations associated with the sloshing water. The other Lagrangian bodies (bottle, cap,
and floor) are modeled the same as in the coupled Eulerian-Lagrangian method.
Mesh design
The pseudo-particles are modeled using PC3D
elements that are spaced in a relatively uniform fashion every 5 mm in all directions.
These one-node elements fill only the space initially occupied by the water just before
the impact. Therefore, fewer PC3D elements
are needed when compared to the number of
EC3D8R elements in the coupled
Eulerian-Lagrangian method.
Interactions
A node-based surface associated with the water pseudo-particle is included in the contact
domain to model the interactions between the water and the bottle.
Case 3 Finite element conversion to SPH particles
analysis
This case shows the use of the technique for converting reduced-integration continuum
elements to SPH particles.
Analysis types
The full simulation is conducted in a single explicit dynamic step lasting 0.05 s.
Analysis Techniques
The water is modeled using reduced-integration continuum
C3D4 elements. A time-based criterion is
used to trigger the conversion from a user-defined mesh to
SPH particles
(PC3D elements) at the beginning of the
analysis. Upon conversion the continuum elements modeling the fluid will become inactive
(deleted from the mesh) while the PC3D
elements get activated. Since all particles get activated at the same time, the
SPH functionality will model the fluid as described in
Case 2.
Mesh design
The water is modeled using reduced-integration continuum
C3D4 elements using regular preprocessing
techniques; the mesh is shown in Figure 4. Thus, cumbersome meshing approaches based on unconnected particles are avoided.
Interactions
Contact between the fluid and the bottle is defined by including an element-based surface
that includes the fluid's interior and its initial external surface in the general contact
domain. Internally, Abaqus/Explicit generates a node-based surface for the generated SPH
particles that will be also included in the contact domain.
Discussion of results and comparison of cases
The results of the drop test in the CEL analysis appear in
Figure 5. (For tips on viewing the results of
CEL analyses, see Viewing output from Eulerian analyses.) The
water contributes significantly to the behavior of the bottle: the bottle flexes and bulges
as the water sloshes. Figure 6 shows the logarithmic strains in the bottle. Strains appear in the sides of the bottle as
they bulge outward, but these strains are largely recovered when the water sloshes upward.
The most significant strains occur on the bottom of the bottle, along the bottle-floor
interface. Despite the deformation caused by the floor and the water, the damage criteria
for the polyethylene is not met at any location on the bottle.
A comparison between the CEL method and the
SPH method at different stages during impact is
illustrated in Figure 7 through Figure 10. The comparison between the two methods is quite reasonable.
The effect of sloshing water can also be seen in the reaction force on the floor surface.
The reaction force in the z-direction is plotted in Figure 11 using a Butterworth filter with a cutoff frequency of 2000. The reaction force peaks
sharply at approximately 0.02 s, which corresponds roughly with the appearance of strains in
the sides of the bottle. After this point, the water surges upward, offsetting the downward
momentum of the bottle and reducing the reaction forces in the floor. Good agreement between
the two methods used is observed.
The significant deformation of the fluid in this problem clearly influences the analysis
results. The coupled Eulerian-Lagrangian and SPH techniques
in Abaqus/Explicit provide an effective way to realistically capture the complexity of the fluid-structure
dynamics.
Files
The basic system of units in this problem is kilograms (kg), millimeters (mm), and seconds
(s). Under this system, the base unit of force is kg mm/s2, or 10−3
newtons; values for all force-derived quantities are entered in the sample files using this
base unit. Values for all force-derived quantities are reported in the documentation in
units of standard newtons (kg m/s2) and scaled appropriately.
Finite element conversion to SPH particles input
file for the model.
Tables
Table 1. Isotropic plastic hardening data for polyethylene material.
Yield stress (N/mm2)
Plastic strain
8.618
0.0
13.064
0.007
16.787
0.025
18.476
0.044
20.337
0.081
24.543
0.28
26.887
0.59
Table 2. Material parameters for water.
Parameter
Value
Density ()
9.96 × 10−7 kg/mm3
Viscosity ()
1 × 10−8 N s/mm2
1.45 × 106 mm/s
s
0
0
Figures
Figure 1. Bottle used in the drop test. All dimensions are in millimeters. Figure 2. Assembly of the bottle drop model; the water is instanced inside of the
bottle. Figure 3. Mesh of the bottle and cap. Figure 4. Tetrahedral mesh to model the fluid in the bottle in the undeformed
configuration. Figure 5. Deformed shape plots of the CEL model at 0.01 s
intervals. Figure 6. Logarithmic strains in the bottle during deformation in the
CEL analysis. Figure 7. Comparison between coupled Eulerian-Lagrangian and
SPH results shortly after the impact. Figure 8. Comparison between coupled Eulerian-Lagrangian and
SPH results after full contact with the floor. Figure 9. Comparison between coupled Eulerian-Lagrangian and
SPH results in the middle stages of the
analysis. Figure 10. Comparison between coupled Eulerian-Lagrangian and
SPH results toward the end of the analysis. Figure 11. Reaction force (filtered) in the floor.